Facebook whistleblower Frances Haugen’s lawyers accuse company of misleading investors about covid and climate misinformation in Securities and Exchange Commission complaints

[ad_1]

One complaint alleges that climate change misinformation was prominently available on Facebook and that the company lacked a clear policy on the issue as recently as last year, despite Facebook executives’ committing to fight the “global crisis” during earnings calls. A second, companion complaint argues that while Facebook executives were publicly touting their efforts to remove harmful covid-19 misinformation, internal documents “paint a different story.” The complaint cites internal company communications about the spread of vaccine hesitancy in comments, and internal surveys that showed the proliferation of covid misinformation on the service.

“Some investors simply will not want to invest in a company that fails to adequately address such misinformation and then engages in misstatements and omissions on the topic,” one complaint says.

Facebook rebranded itself as Meta last year, after Haugen left the company and went public as a whistleblower. The company continues to remove false claims about vaccines, and that it has worked to elevate “authoritative information” about both climate change and public health, Meta spokesman Drew Pusateri said.

“There are no one-size-fits-all solutions to stopping the spread of misinformation, but we’re committed to building new tools and policies to combat it,” Pusateri told The Post in a statement.

For years Democrats have criticized social networks over what they argue is a negligent approach to misinformation about public health, democracy and the environment. The White House last year pressured Facebook to do more to address vaccine misinformation, a push that cumulated in President Biden telling reporters “they’re killing people.” But despite public fireworks, policymakers and regulators in the interim have taken little action to rein in the proliferation of falsehoods online, in part because many proposals targeting misinformation risk running afoul of the First Amendment.

Haugen’s lawyers have sidestepped this concern by focusing their complaints on corporate interests: whether the company has lied to investors.

Nathaniel Persily, a professor at Stanford Law School and director of the Stanford Cyber Policy Center called the strategy a “creative” approach to the problem. “You cannot pass a law in the U.S. banning disinformation,” Persily said. “So what can you do? You can hold the platforms accountable to promises they make. Those promises could be made to users, to the government, to shareholders.”

While the SEC has not publicly commented on the status of Haugen’s complains, the agency has signaled a “very strong enforcement stance” under Democratic chairman Gary Gensler, said Jane Norberg, who headed the SEC’s whistleblower program until April and is now a partner at Arnold & Porter, a law firm that specializes in business regulation. (Haugen sought whistleblower protection from the SEC, which could protect her from retaliation from Facebook.) The agency has broadly been clear that companies need to make clear and accurate disclosures to investors, Norberg said.

“If the company says one thing to investors, but internal documents show that what they were saying is untrue, that could be something the SEC would look at,” she said.

The SEC did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the status of the complaints.

A congressional staffer shared redacted versions of the SEC complaints with a consortium of news organizations, including The Washington Post. The complaints cite confidential documents, originally collected by Haugen, also shared with the consortium.

The climate change complaint, filed with the SEC on Feb. 7, cites records that show employees internally grappling with the company’s perceived role in spreading climate misinformation. In a document from the first quarter of 2021, an employee said they searched for “climate change” in the social network’s Watch tab. The second result was a piece of “climate misinfo,” the employee wrote, and had been viewed more than 6.6 million times.

Another employee working in Facebook’s search integrity called for the company to do more to address climate denialism. “Can we take it a step farther and start classifying and removing climate misinformation and hoaxes from our platforms,” they wrote.

The complaint also cites internal records about the platform’s Climate Science Information Center, a much-touted hub designed to connect people with authoritative climate information. Awareness of the webpage was “very low,” even for people who had visited it.

“Climate change knowledge is generally poor,” one of the internal reports from 2021 said. “Given how many people use Facebook for information about climate change … climate science myths are a problem across all surveyed markets.”

The filing’s argue that it’s particularly urgent that Facebook tackle climate change misinformation, in part because of the popularity of the site. An internal company documents cited in the complaint says that Facebook is the second most common source for news related to climate change, behind only television news and ahead of news aggregators, movies, online climate news sources and other social media platforms.

The company adds information labels to some posts about climate change, and it reduces distribution of posts that its fact checking partners rate as false. But it generally does not remove those posts, as it does with certain false claims about vaccines and the coronavirus. Michael Mann, the director of the Earth System Science Center at the Pennsylvania State University, called the company’s approach “disturbing.”

“Unmitigated climate change is projected to lead to far greater numbers of human fatalities than covid-19,” said Mann, the author of “The New Climate War.” “The fact that they’re treating greater threat with so much less urgency and care is problematic.”

Pusateri, the Meta spokesman, says climate misinformation makes up a small amount of climate change content in its apps, and that it spikes periodically, such as during extreme weather events. The company has taken steps to make it easier for fact-checkers to find climate content.

In the other filing, dated Feb. 10, the Whistleblower lawyers argue that internal documents showing the spread of covid-19 misinformation contradict the public statements the company was made. An internal Facebook document cited in the complaint shows that in April 2020, the company saw a 20 percent spike in users reporting and seeing false or misleading content. A Facebook employee cites covid as a reason. The complaint cites a May 2020 company record, where employees warned hundreds of anti-quarantine groups were active, with many high-ranking comments linking to conspiracies about covid-19. The SEC complaint also cites an internal Facebook survey, which found one in three people in the United States said they saw misleading or false information related to covid-19 and voting.

The Washington Post previously reported that coronavirus misinformation was dominating small sections of its platform, creating “echo-chamber-like effects” and reinforcing vaccine hesitancy. Other researchers documented how posts by medical authorities, like the World Health Organization, were often swarmed by anti-vaccine commenters. These documents were also cited in the complaint.

The filings are part of Haugen’s team’s broader legal strategy. Her lawyers filed at least eight other complaints last year with the agency based on the trove of company documents. One complaint alleges that the company misled investors about its role in “perpetuating misinformation and violent extremism relating to the 2020 election and January 6 insurrection.” Others accused the company of misleading investors about its removal of hate speech, and the negative consequences of its algorithms promoting misinformation and hate speech.

Persily, the Stanford Law professor, said complaints like this could be a model for how to regulate in the area of content moderation. “It is extremely difficult to enact regulation regarding content moderation because it’s such a fast moving area,” he said. “If you do hold the platforms to rules that they agree to, that’s a different mode of regulation.”

[ad_2]

Source link

Trending Topics

Features

Download and distribute powerful vaccination QI resources for your community.

Sign up now to support health equity and sustainable health outcomes in your community.

MCED tests use a simple blood draw to screen for many kinds of cancer at once.

FYHN is a bridge connecting health information providers to BIPOC communities in a trusted environment.

Discover an honest look at our Medicare system.

ARC was launched to create a network of community clinicians to diversify and bring clinical trials to communities of color and other communities that have been underrepresented.

The single most important purpose of our healthcare system is to reduce patient risk for an acute event.

Related Posts
Could Heart Failure Be ATTR-CM? What Patients Should Know
Metastatic Breast Cancer Treatment: FDA Approves New Option
RSV Season Is Approaching, What Parents Need to Know
Scroll to Top
Featured Articles
ID 295848269 ©  Yuri  Arcurs | Dreamstime.com
Could Heart Failure Be ATTR-CM? What Patients Should Know
Blood test used to help guide metastatic breast cancer treatment decisions.
Metastatic Breast Cancer Treatment: FDA Approves New Option
ID 303329068 | Rsv ©  Seventyfourimages | Dreamstime.com
RSV Season Is Approaching, What Parents Need to Know
Alzheimer’s Awareness During World Alzheimer’s Month
Resource Roundup: Tools to Help Families Talk About Memory Changes
Trish Tabor
Black woman speaking with a health care provider about cancer screening and early detection.
Cancer Deaths Are Down 35%. Finding Cancer Earlier Is Next
ID 194306501 | Doctor ©  Hector Pertuz | Dreamstime.com
Hispanic Heritage Month Starts With a Health Question About Heart Disease
Categories
AI
ATTR-CM
BIPOC News
Cancer
Clinical Trials
Covid19
Diseases of the Body
Environment
Health Data
Health Equity Events
Health Policy
Health Tips
Subscribe to our newsletter to receive our latest news​
All Stories
ID 295848269 ©  Yuri  Arcurs | Dreamstime.com
Could Heart Failure Be ATTR-CM? What Patients Should Know
Blood test used to help guide metastatic breast cancer treatment decisions.
Metastatic Breast Cancer Treatment: FDA Approves New Option
ID 303329068 | Rsv ©  Seventyfourimages | Dreamstime.com
RSV Season Is Approaching, What Parents Need to Know
BIPOC News
ID 295848269 ©  Yuri  Arcurs | Dreamstime.com
Could Heart Failure Be ATTR-CM? What Patients Should Know
ID 303329068 | Rsv ©  Seventyfourimages | Dreamstime.com
RSV Season Is Approaching, What Parents Need to Know
Alzheimer’s Awareness During World Alzheimer’s Month
Resource Roundup: Tools to Help Families Talk About Memory Changes
Trish Tabor
Environment
Gary, Indiana Tap Water Raises Health and Environmental Justice Concerns
Gary, Indiana Tap Water Raises Health and Environmental Justice Concerns
UV Safety Awareness Month Raises Urgency on Skin Cancer Prevention and Sun Protection Equity
UV Safety Awareness Month Raises Urgency on Skin Cancer Prevention and Sun Pr...
Extreme Heat Safety Tips 5 Ways to Protect Your Health This Summer fyh.news
5 Heat Safety Tips That Could Protect Your Health This Summer
Work Force
A multigenerational Black and Hispanic family sitting together in a park, showing how Social Security helps support older adults, people with disabilities, and families across generations.
Millions of Older Americans Could Face Smaller Social Security Checks by 2032...
dreamstime_s_243253251
The Caregiver Journey: The Hidden Backbone of American Healthcare
Families gather at a Bronx community festival with live music, kids’ activities, and health booths sharing SOMOS social care resources and free screenings.
Celebrating Hispanic heritage while learning about health care

[xyz-ips snippet=”Output-Source-Name”]

Clinical Trials
ID 467708657 | Black Doctor ©  Fizkes | Dreamstime.com
Multi-Cancer Early Detection Could Shift Cancer Earlier, But Who Has Access?
Historic Cancer Leadership Milestone Highlights the Importance of Early Detection and Community Outreach
Historic Cancer Leadership Milestone Highlights the Importance of Early Detec...
House Advances Bipartisan EARLY Act Reauthorization, Renewing Focus on Early Breast Cancer Detection for Young Women
House Advances Bipartisan EARLY Act Reauthorization, Renewing Focus on Early ...
Vaccines and Outbreaks
Summer COVID Surge Builds Across U.S. Fyh.news
Summer COVID Surge Builds Across U.S. as Cases Rise Again
Class I Salmonella Egg Recall What to Know Fyh.news
FDA Gives Egg Recall Highest-Risk Class I Designation Over Salmonella Outbreak
Taylor Farms Recalls Jalapeño-Containing Foods as Salmonella Outbreak Sickens 345 Across 27 States
Taylor Farms Recalls Jalapeño-Containing Foods as Salmonella Outbreak Sickens...
Other Categories
AI
Read the latest AI News stories trending around the world
ATTR-CM
Cancer
Read the latest Cancer stories trending around the world
Covid19
Diseases of the Body
Read about the latest Diseases of the Body trending around the world
Friday Webinars
Every Friday, we bring you insightful webinars covering critical topics in healthcare, data equity, and policy reform.
Health Data
Read the latest Health Data stories trending around the world
Health Equity Events
Read the best Health Equity Events around the country.
Health Policy
Read the latest Health Policy stories trending around the world
Health Tips
Heart Health
Read the latest on Heart Health News, Stories and Tips.
kidney Health
Read more trending News about Kidney Health, Stories and Tips.