Purpose:

The purpose of our study was to describe the influences that impact vaccine hesitancy in African American parents who have previously delayed or denied vaccinating their children against HPV.

Methods:

We conducted three focus groups, approx. 90 minutes each. Participants were recruited from various community clinics and organizations in Michigan. Using thematic analysis and the Vaccine Hesitancy Determinants framework, we described the experiences of parents who have delayed or denied vaccinating their children against HPV.

Results:

Twenty parents participated in the focus groups; the majority of the parents had Medicaid (75%), were employed full-time (55%), and had some college education but no degree (50%). Several contextual factors influenced decision-making: historical events, perceptions of both pharmaceutical and governmental figures, and perceived discrimination based on race and socioeconomic status. Whether it was the result of mistrust due to the ongoing Flint water crisis or concern over the profit-driven industry of pharmaceutical companies, these parents were deeply mistrustful of the motivations behind vaccination programs. Parental beliefs and attitudes focused on ensuring the health and safety of their children, which involved being hesitant to vaccinate. Some parents were swayed by vaccination experiences of personal acquaintances, while others maintained their hesitancy status. Knowledge and awareness in this group were mixed regarding the HPV vaccine. Most struggled to articulate the purpose of the vaccine thoroughly and often refused to vaccinate their children. Meanwhile, only a few vaccine-specific issues were relevant in group discussions, such as vaccination schedule and provider recommendation. Some parents viewed weak recommendations as a subtle signal to not vaccinate their children, while others viewed too strong of a recommendation as a cause for concern.

Conclusion:

Findings highlight parents’ willingness to stick with their strong beliefs, despite recommendations from healthcare providers and personal acquaintances. Effective communications strategies are essential for health education and establishing a trustworthy patient-provider relationship.